Zach Aarons • June 5, 2012Probably the best carrot cake in New York. Not quite worth the hike up to Riverdale, but if you happen to be there it's a must. (3 of 4 petals via Fondu)
Paula P. • August 3, 2017Best landmark Italian bakery. Love their bread & cannolis <3
Serious Eats • May 22, 2014Madonia might be the only bakery in New York still producing traditional lard bread; that is, made with roast pork.
JenRey69 • December 25, 2014Beef patties, chicken patties, cinnamon raisin bread, rum cake, all delish!
Rodney W. • December 27, 2014Love this bakery! Been getting birthday cakes from here ever since I can remember. The cakes are not only beautiful, but delicious! Definitely will always be my go to for cakes for any occasion!
8and9.com .. • July 18, 2010They have the best cookies ever....they also have sugar free cookies, cakes and pies.
CITY GRIT • August 3, 2014We can't believe an Italian Bakery introduced us to Lard Bread! Praise the Lard they did!
gabi p. • July 16, 2009order a raisin roll with butter for breakfast, or if you're bringing dessert get the Mexican cinnamon cookies.
Miss Butterfly • April 18, 2011Amazing cakes. Best is vanilla or chocolate cake with butter cream icing on the inside and out.
Marlon • November 20, 2021Classic shop with great tasting cheesecake and the owners are well aware of this… Jackie O was a notable S&S customer
Denisa • September 11, 2019The desserts are amazing! The tres leches & flan in a cup is my favorite.
Ade L. • September 21, 2017I love that this bakery opens 24 hours. I ordered cakes on different occasions and they were delicious
Julie V. • February 13, 2015Best bakery I've been to since I was a kid! Old school, homemade, Italian deliciousness! Came on the recommendation of a coworker who grew up in the Bronx, and I'm never going to another bakery again!
Alice B. • May 9, 2014I love their Tortas!
John S. • December 27, 2016Delicious!! The sandwiches are excellent!! One of the best deli's / bakeries in Morris Park!!!
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.